Captain America: Brave New World (2025) - A New Era for Heroes

Captain America: Brave New World (2025) was always going to be divisive. Regardless of the final product, some viewers will either praise or deride its choices. Nuance is scarce in the vast desert of the internet. Let’s address a common refrain: “Why do we need a Black [insert character]? Why can’t we create our own?”

via Marvel.com

Understanding Sam Wilson as Captain America

It's crucial to clarify upfront: Sam Wilson is not merely a “Black version of Captain America.” He is Captain America, and he just happens to be Black. “Captain America” is a title, a mantle that can be passed on, just like they want John Walker to take on that role. This title is not a part of one's identity, but rather a marker of responsibility.

Furthermore, Sam Wilson is not just a race-swapped version of Steve Rogers. Marvel didn't merely paint over the original character. Sam has his own unique backstory and faces challenges that are entirely different from those of Steve Rogers. The same applies to other characters like Miles Morales and Nubia.

The Importance of Unique Narratives

The Grey | Midnight Comics

As the blog editor for a Black-owned indie comic company, I must emphasize that we do have “our own” narratives. Lloyd and Natosha Jones have created a rich universe with Midnight Comics featuring characters like Sol and The Grey. Meanwhile, Brent Trayce Sands developed Impound Comics inspired by iconic comics and martial arts films. At GodHood Comics, you can dive into The Antagonists, where a parenting duo of supervillains tries to bury their past.

There are countless original Black characters thriving in unique universes across the globe. The question we face may be more about consumer interest than availability.

The Ongoing Debate: Inclusion vs. Creation

This conversation will likely persist for years. One of the most significant issues surrounding “Blackness is not a monolith” comes into play here. Do we need a seat at the table of mainstream comics, or should we establish our own? The answer lies in embracing both paths.

It's counterproductive to undermine those who choose to pursue "the majors." Not everyone is cut out for the entrepreneurial journey. If we shame someone for not creating independently, we risk stifling incredible storytelling. We must nurture talents, especially those that can shine under established platforms.

Conversely, suggesting to indie artists, “Why don’t you work for Marvel, Tyler Perry, or BET?” implies that their achievements are only valid if endorsed by traditional avenues. This line of thinking is disrespectful and dismisses the hard work and passion driving independent creators.

via BookRiot.com

Supporting Black Characters

So, no, we do not NEED a “Black Captain America.” We need those who are passionate about Black characters and the ongoing legacy of Black excellence to show up. Support the art you want to see with tangible actions.

Show up when your favored established character gets a solo run. Participate when new, engaging characters seek funding through Kickstarters. By actively supporting compelling stories, we can reduce the need for this ongoing debate.

Concluding Thoughts

Real change comes from engagement. The desire for diverse representation can be fulfilled by nurturing a more inclusive landscape. When we support characters in every genre, we create a richer tapestry of storytelling that honors all voices.

Whether it's helping established franchises or fostering new indie stories, there’s space for everyone. Instead of creating divisiveness, let’s celebrate the diversity of characters and stories that reflect our world.

In this ever-evolving comic landscape, understanding the nuances and supporting creators on all fronts ensures that diverse narratives continue to thrive. Remember, we each play a role in shaping the future of storytelling.